【occidental grand punta cana royal club】When Is It OK to Pay Fact Witnesses? Florida Justices Weigh In
Witness stand. Photo: Bigstock.
Theoccidental grand punta cana royal club Florida Supreme Court ruled that fact witnesses can only be paid to assist with cases in certain circumstances, following a firm's request to recover fees in a breach-of-contract lawsuit.
While Naples law firm Hahn Loeser & Parks claimed it should be reimbursed for paying witnesses to assist with case and discovery preparation, legal consulting company Trial Practices Inc. argued that allowing payments to fact witnesses could be construed as encouraging them to testify in one party's favor.
Florida Supreme Court Chief Justice Charles T. Canady. Photo: WFSU.
The justices considered
Florida Bar Rule 4-3.4(b)
, which governs witness payments, guards against false testimony and says that parties can provide "reasonable compensation" to a witness. What's reasonable, according to the court opinion, all depends on the circumstances.
The underlying case centered on a long-running million-dollar dispute between business partners Jack J. Antaramian and David E. Nassif. Antaramian had agreed to a fee-shifting provision with Trial Practices, promising 5 percent of the money recovered. But after a mistrial and subsequent settlement, Trial Practices sued Antaramian for its share.
A jury rendered a defense verdict in 2011, so Antaramian moved for more than $700,000 in fees and costs. Of that, he claimed $236,000 went to seven fact witnesses at professional firms — the majority to Boston-based firm Burns & Levinson, according to the opinion.
Chief Justice Charles T. Canady wrote
the opinion
, ruling that without detailed information about how the costs were broken down, the case likely didn't fit any scenario in which it's OK to pay fact witnesses.
Justices Barbara Pariente, Peggy Quince, Ricky Polston and Alan Lawson agreed, and Justice R. Fred Lewis concurred in the result.
Read the full court opinion:
falcon-embed src="embed_1"
Counsel to Trial Practices,
G. Donovan Conwell Jr
. of Conwell Business Law in Tampa, was pleased with the decision as he argued that allowing payments to witnesses would create opportunities for abuse.
"Every fact witness could then be hired by the party with the most money, and the integrity of the judicial system would be comprised," Conwell said. "The other side had argued that it was OK to hire a fact witness and pay them consultant fees of basically $500 to $600 an hour."
Lawyers for Hahn Loeser,
Edmond E. Koester
and
Matthew B. Devisse
of Coleman, Yovanovich & Koester in Naples, did not respond to requests for comment before deadline.
Story continues
'A very fine line'
Joel S. Perwin, of Joel S. Perwin, Miami. Photo: J. Albert Diaz/ALM.
According to veteran state and federal appellate lawyer
Joel S. Perwin
in Miami, the court seemed to struggle with its interpretation of the rule.
"You don't want to provide any kind of financial incentive for the witness to do anything but be objective and to help you out," Perwin said. "So the court is walking a very fine line in trying to interpret that language and be true to that distinction."
Litigants can buy fact witnesses' help with a case, according to the opinion, but only if it's directly related to a witness preparing for, attending or testifying in court.
"It does not allow a payment for assistance with the case and preparing for discovery and other things that the lawyer does," Perwin said.
The way Perwin sees it, if it's not something a fact witness typically does, it shouldn't be paid for during a case. Litigants can also pay fact witnesses who lose money by showing up or preparing to testify, according to the opinion.
While expert witnesses are typically brought in to break down complicated subject matter to jurors, fact witnesses are called to explain aspects of the case that they saw, heard or experienced in some way.
"A fact witness is really only supposed to tell you, 'Here's what happened, here's what I was involved in,' " Perwin said.
The case will return to the trial court for a closer look at the cost breakdown.
View comments
(责任编辑:Knowledge)
- Skeljungur hf.: Changes to terms in market making agreements
- Toy CEO says it 'sickens' him that people profit from a shortage of supplies to fight coronavirus
- JPMorgan Chase approved to process $15 billion in new PPP loans
- RTX CLASS ACTION FILING DEADLINE: Bernstein Liebhard LLP Reminds Investors of the Deadline to File a Lead Plaintiff Motion in a Securities Class Action Lawsuit Against Raytheon Technologies Corporation
- Why You Should Leave Strix Group Plc's (LON:KETL) Upcoming Dividend On The Shelf
- IMPORTANT INVESTOR NOTICE: The Schall Law Firm Announces the Filing of a Class Action Lawsuit Against PaySign, Inc. and Encourages Investors with Losses in Excess of $100,000 to Contact the Firm
- Global watchdog warns over financial staff curbs in pandemic
- Pence will meet cruise industry officials Saturday on coronavirus
- S&P 500 Preview – Security Software and Retail Headline Tuesday’s Earnings
- Genesco (GCO) Gains But Lags Market: What You Should Know
- Trex (TREX) Q1 Earnings and Revenues Surpass Estimates
- More drugmakers hike U.S. prices as new year begins
- Memgen Announces Addition to Board of Directors
-
35 Surprising Cities With Low Costs of Living
Cleveland, Ohio, USA downtown city skyline and harbor at twilight.If you’re struggling to make ends ...[详细] -
Pompeo says U.S. considering welcoming Hong Kong people, entrepreneurs
WASHINGTON, June 1 (Reuters) - The United States is considering the option of welcoming people from ...[详细] -
Accepted Abstract will Showcase Clinical Data on Investigational Drug Rhenium NanoLiposomes (RNL™)AU ...[详细]
-
NextEra Energy (NEE) Stock Moves -1.57%: What You Should Know
NextEra Energy (NEE) closed the most recent trading day at $271.82, moving -1.57% from the previous ...[详细] -
Energy Fuels Inc.'s (TSE:EFR) Intrinsic Value Is Potentially 96% Above Its Share Price
Today we'll do a simple run through of a valuation method used to estimate the attractiveness of Ene ...[详细] -
Ex-Tesla employee agrees to pay $400K over claims he stole trade secrets
Tesla Inc CEO Elon Musk speaks at an opening ceremony for Tesla China-made Model Y program in Shangh ...[详细] -
NEW YORK, NY / ACCESSWIRE / May 5, 2020 /Labaton Sucharow LLP, a leading and award winning investor ...[详细]
-
Media Stock Earnings Roster This Week: DISCA, FOXA & More
Media companies’ quarterly earnings are expected to have gained traction from solid demand for onlin ...[详细] -
SEC delays decision on tZERO’s proposed security token exchange
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has delayed the decision of approving or disapprov ...[详细] -
Evotec to Attend Upcoming Investor Conferences
HAMBURG, GERMANY / ACCESSWIRE / November 4, 2020 /Evotec SE (Frankfurt Stock Exchange: EVT, MDAX/Tec ...[详细]
Lockheed Martin (LMT) Wins $1B Deal for Super Hercules Fleet
Why Semtech (SMTC) Stock Might be a Great Pick
- Were Hedge Funds Right About Caterpillar (CAT)?
- Data Gumbo Joins Blockchain In Transport Alliance
- Monterey Minerals Provides Update on Drill Program
- Gatling Discovers 3rd High-Grade Gold Trend at Kir Vit; Encounters Highest Grades to Date
- Unknown gunmen kill three in daylight in Afghan capital Kabul
- Avista (AVA) Misses Q3 Earnings and Revenue Estimates
- Global watchdog warns over financial staff curbs in pandemic